Keene A52 Hand Sluice vs Keene A51 Mini Sluice

Two sluice boxes compared using only what their Gold Output catalog pages state: intended use, setup, cost inputs, strengths, and limits.

At a glance

Side-by-side facts for Keene A52 Hand Sluice and Keene A51 Mini Sluice
FactKeene A52 Hand SluiceKeene A51 Mini Sluice
Average price$155.00$66.00 more$89.00$66.00 less
MSRP$169.99$99.99
Tracked price range$140.00 – $180.00$75.00 – $110.00
Weight12 lbs6 lbs
Key specIdeal for 1-2 peopleIdeal for solo prospecting
Expertisebeginnerbeginner
Popularity★★★★☆ 9/10★★★★☆ 8/10

Prices are the catalog's tracked reference prices, not live offers.

Intended use

Keene A52 Hand Sluice

Recreational prospecting for one or two people. The catalog describes the A52 as the legendary full-size hand sluice, with proven performance in the field.

Keene A51 Mini Sluice

Backpacking and smaller operations. The catalog calls the A51 the compact version of the famous A52, ideal for solo prospecting.

Setup and handling

Keene A52 Hand Sluice

A 50-inch by 10-inch aluminum box with riffles, an adjustable leg, and a flare, weighing 12 pounds.

Keene A51 Mini Sluice

A 33-inch by 6-inch aluminum box with riffles, weighing 6 pounds — sized to carry into the field.

Cost inputs for the calculator

Whichever you pick, the purchase price is a fixed cost in the Gold Output profitability calculator: enter the price you actually pay under fixed costs, and any per-hour costs separately. The table above gives each product's tracked reference price as a starting point.

Keene A52 Hand Sluice

Use $155.00 — the tracked average — or your real purchase price as the fixed cost.

Keene A51 Mini Sluice

Use $89.00 — the tracked average — or your real purchase price as the fixed cost.

Open the profitability calculator

Strengths

Keene A52 Hand Sluice

  • Larger working surface: 50 by 10 inches versus the A51's 33 by 6
  • Adjustable leg and flare are part of the listed design
  • Rated 9/10 for popularity, the higher of the two

Keene A51 Mini Sluice

  • Half the A52's weight at 6 pounds, made for backpacking
  • Lower catalog price than the A52 (see the price table)
  • Same riffled aluminum design family as the A52, in compact form

Limits

Keene A52 Hand Sluice

  • 12 pounds to carry, twice the A51's 6-pound weight
  • The higher average price of the pair (see the price table)
  • Not the compact option: the catalog points backpackers to the A51

Keene A51 Mini Sluice

  • Smaller working surface: 33 by 6 inches versus the A52's 50 by 10
  • Rated 8/10 for popularity, a step under the A52's 9/10
  • Cataloged for solo prospecting rather than 1–2 person sessions